Diagnosing the Late Summer Swoon

As we all know, the Nats seemed to be in a decent position headed into the All Star Break. They were 48-39, and two games up on the Mets.  But more importantly, they were just two weeks away from regaining the services of Ryan Zimmerman, Anthony Rendon, and Jayson Werth.  Despite facing a veritable plethora of Cy Young candidates right out of the box in the second half (Kershaw, Grienke, Harvey, de Grom, Syndergaard, Liriano, AJ Burnett, Cole, Jose Fernandez), they still managed 6-8 for the rest of July, and despite losing to the Mets on the last day of the month, they still had a two game lead as July ended.

But then August came and the bottom fell out.  The Nats were 12-17 in August while the Mets went 20-8, resulting in an 8.5 game loss in the standings.

What in the world happened?

There were a number of reasons.  Pitching, both starting and relief, disappeared.  The Nats team ERA was 4.48 in August, compared to 3.23 in July.  Scherzer went 0-3 in 5 starts, with an ERA of 6.43 for the month.  Storen, after allowing only 4 hits and 0 runs in July, started August with 3 hitless innings, but then had an incredibly horrible streak of four straight games where he gave up at least two runs.  And then another run two appearances later.  (Other pitchers faltered, too, but those two examples are enough)

But there was another major factor that was a bit less obvious: that three stars came back in the space of three days, and all had prolonged trouble at the plate, as they were playing their spring training in August.  I find the following statistics eye-popping:

Werth returned July 28.  In his first 19 games back (after missing 60), he hit .145 — since then, in the 15 games since then, he’s hit .303 with 3 HR’s (and 6 doubles, a triple, and 15 runs scored).

Rendon returned July 25, after coming back from his second injury.  In his first 23 games back he hit .200. Since then, in 12 games, he’s hit .362 — and has a 12 game hitting streak going.

During those 19 games when neither Werth nor Rendon were hitting, Nats were 5-14.  In the last 16, the Nats are 10-6, despite continued inconsistent pitching.

Ryan Zimmerman came back hitting the ball hard (on July 28), but not quite for average.  In his first 25 games back from injury, after missing 39 games, he hit .253 — but that’s a bit deceptive.  It consisted of 9 games hitting .219, followed by 5 great games at .563, but ended with 11 games batting .129 (during which the Nats were 3-8).  But since then, in his last 11 games, he’s .405 with 7 HR’s, 6 doubles, and 23 RBIs.

Williams and Rizzo faced a tough situation.  They knew these hitters would eventually get on track – they always have – but they also knew that they’d have to suffer through their “spring trainings” for a while to get there.  And not only that, but to have three guys in the lineup going through spring training at the same time was going to hurt.  Would it be worth it?  Or should the team continue to play the likes of Clint Robinson, et al, in the field?  The certainly bench did a yeoman’s job before the All Star Break — and, after all, they helped the team to 1st place.  On the other hand, do you really want to go into the September stretch relying on CRob and Espinosa rather than Werth, Two Bags, and Zim?

So, the Nats bit the bullet, and played these guys through their August spring training.  It certainly seemed like the typical smart long range plan that Rizzo is well known for; and, at the least, it was a defensible decision.  And, just as the organization hoped, all three have gotten their hitting groove back and then some.  Having all three hitting over .300 for a stretch (while Harper and Escobar continue to hit at .300+) is exactly what we’ve been waiting for all season.  But we all know the problem: the spring training cold spell perfectly coincided with the Mets getting super hot.  After hitting .227 in June and .237 in July, the Mets hit .269 in August and scored 150 more runs than the month prior.

So now the Nats seem to be hitting September on most of their cylinders, at least on offense.  Can they put together a streak and catch the Mets?  But, just as certain as their hitting seems to be right now, they certainly haven’t left themselves a lot of time, and certainly still have a number of questions regarding their pitching: can Scherzer get it together again?  (He showed promise two night ago)  Ditto for Storen.  How long will Joe Ross last?  What’s up with Strasburg’s newest back kink?  Is Gio reverting to the “bad” Gio we saw in April and May?  Will Roark regain last year’s form now that he’s starting?

But of course the Mets have questions, too.  And the most obvious ones relate to their three young guns and whether they are running out of gas (Syndergaard, who just turned 23 last week, has allowed 3 runs or more in 5 of his last 6 starts) or will hit innings limits (the 26 year old Harvey, 1 year after TJ surgery is at 166 innings; deGrom is 27, pitched 140 last year, and is up to 163).  Their team ERA for August was over a 1/2 run higher than July, but few noticed because their offense was so explosive.  But as their offense reverts to the mean, all eyes will be on the incredibly talented young trio they’ve assembled.

The Nats went through a fairly unique situation: having three very talented stars (some forget how good they’ve been: during the 2012 thru 2014 seasons combined, Werth hit  .303, with an OBP of .394, and his OPS was top 10 in NL in each of 2013 & 2014; Rendon finished 5th in MVP last year, won a silver slugger, and finished 2nd in the NL in bWAR for position players) — all three coming back at exactly the same time, and all three battling spring-training slumps at the same time.  That wasn’t the sole cause of the swoon, but it was a big factor.  Thankfully, that’s over now, and we have every baseball fan’s wish: meaningful games in September and a pennant race — although the hole is uncomfortably deep.

Here’s hoping that with the last two nights, the summer swoon is over, and the Nats can reel off some serious winning streaks – including that three game series with the Mets coming up!

This entry was posted in Analysis. Bookmark the permalink.
  • Small, but important correction. DeGrom actually pitched 180 innings last year (you left out the minor leagues innings), and at 27 years old, he no longer has a limit and shouldn’t necessarily be expected to fade.


      Thanks for the correction. First off, yes, I spaced on the minor league innings. Nice catch.

      As for his age: according to the “Verducci Effect” (as some call is, as Tom Verducci of SI first wrote about it), the ramp up in innings needs to be managed up until a pitcher is around age 26. So you may be correct (which, actually, is why I included deGrom’s age in there) on that (and certainly correct that minor league innings count, too!)

      Well played, 112! I agree with you: just Harvey and “Thor” pose potential problems for the Mets, not deGrom.

      • Well – since I helped take one off the list, I was hoping to add one. Looking at Familia, he has pitched a lot of innings and will pass last year, but not by a lot. That said, his performance in the second half has been slipping which may reflect more high stress innings now that he’s a full time closer. Grasping at straws here.

  • AllstarsSportsMarketing

    First Zmunchkin’s excellent post and now this.

    Great to ponder all the food for thought and how many times in a sports blog would you read the words “veritable plethora”!

    • Ghost of Steve M.

      Only way to describe the “Murderer’s Row” of Cy candidates the Nats faced in Kershaw, Grienke, Harvey, de Grom, Syndergaard, Liriano, AJ Burnett, Cole, Jose Fernandez in that period. Talk about your odds of facing a team’s Big 3 of starters.

  • masterfishkeeper

    This is interesting, but why did the three returning players struggle so much? David Wright has an OPS of .851 in his first 8 games back.


      Some players, apparently, don’t. Denard Span is another who comes to mind . . .

      (Although for Wright, perhaps it helped that 6 of his 8 games back so far has been against Phillie’s pitching? 😉 )

    • I’ve wondered this as well.

    • zmunchkin

      And, I believe, he had a full spring training and beginning of the season while healthy. None of Werth, Rendon or Zimmerman had that.

    • I don’t think it makes sense to take Wright’s performance as the expectation and ask why they failed to meet it. Wright is exceeding his career norms right now.

      My guess is that if you survey established MLB players who performed at a high level and then missed significant periods of time due to injury, you would find that their performance immediately after return on average looks more like the pattern with Werth and Rendon than with Wright.

      • PS

        Kudos to Ghost and everyone else who is making this site work and making it better.

        Just saw the “Click to edit” button for the first time (my first post since it was added). Very cool!

  • NataFan2005

    “But then August came and the bottom fell out. The Nats were 12-17 in August while the Mets went 20-8, resulting in an 8.5 game loss in the standings.

    What in the world happened?”

    Something we’ve all wondered about going from the drivers seat to the back seat.

    • NatsRedux

      It wasn’t like the Nats were getting blown out in those games.

  • Ghost of Steve M.

    Wonk, great post and congratulations on your 1st one on TalkNats!


      Thanks for the kind words — I do hope to write more in the future.

      • Ghost of Steve M.

        Sure hope you do!

        This could be the piece to turn back to if the Nats don’t make the post-season to re-read this as to the August “bust” and what happened.

        • zmunchkin

          Ditto to both of Ghost’s comments.

          • senators69

            Agreed! Thank you ADC.

      • rayvil01

        Great post, Wonk!

  • senators69

    Off topic here, but the “new website” story is way down…
    Question: When may we see the “Like” button back and the comments sort function (previously discussed)?
    Thanks again for a great website!

    • Ghost of Steve M.

      Those will come when the migration is made to Disqus which is what you see MASN use for their Blog format.

      Right now Scott and Brandon and their group at Image Works Creative are doing phased in changes.

      The 3 main things in Phase 1 was to get to the TalkNats.com dedicated domain to handle the traffic and get this more “user friendly” as we are getting almost 20,000 for the week (yah, I know, hard to believe), then add in the Edit button, and then get the comments box at the top with the order at the newest first. They accomplished all of that and also did some site beautification and established some TalkNats email addresses, and getting legit press credentials and a photo account where we can use licensed photos the right way.

      Phase II will be the improved looking site and then some ad space to hopefully generate some money for the 2 men who have spent $1,000s bankrolling this gargantuan effort. All I do is write and moderate and encourage and suggest and comment and suggest some more. The IWC team has put in a lot of people time in this and along with the group at Allstars Sports Marketing will make this the best site in the Nats blogosphere.

      • senators69

        Thank you, Steve.

        I posted the question since it is probably also of interest to others as well as me.

        It’s already become a great site in short order. But once complete, I think it will be easier to drive even more traffic here through improved ease of use.

        Very happy you got the press credentials too!

        • What he said. Thanks, folks.

        • Ghost of Steve M.

          On the new posts you will see the LIKES are back.

          • Steve, not so fast! I am testing a Like module for the comments but was unable to get it configured completely yet. It does look like the Like button will be making a comeback in the near future though!

    • zmunchkin

      Ghost, do you want the pin the new site story to the first page – that will keep it at the top.

      • Ghost of Steve M.

        I wonder if we can repost in a few days to move it up.

        • Don’t need to. Just wait and pin it then, if you want it to fall and then come back to the top. Easier, and less confusing to the readers, than reposting or posting a link.

      • I am having a problem with the navigation. I can never remember if the old and new posts are left-right, or right-left, respectively.